Roger the Dog and Do You Carrot All For Me?
Your response needs to be a paragraph with at least 3 sentences, but you do not need to summarize the meaning of the poems. Instead, your response should include the following information:
- Which poem's meaning is more important to you?
- What personal connection can you make?
- Which poet's craft do you enjoy more? Poet's craft can include repetition, word choice, rhyme, simile/metaphor, etc.
Do You Carrot All For Me is more meaningful to me because it is about a boy asking his mom if she cares at all for him.
ReplyDeleteI can make a connection with Roger The Dog because my cat is also super lazy.
I choose the winner to be Roger The Dog because it would always make me laugh and I can understand it.
Do you carrot all for me has a deeper meaning to me because it is about a man who is asking his wife If she cares about him.
ReplyDeleteI can make a connection with Roger the dog because my dog is just like Roger.
I chose Roger the dog because I made a connection with it.
I think Do You Carrot All For Me is about a girl who has a crush, and it uses word play.
ReplyDeleteI think Roger the Dog is about a very lazy dog that only wants to sleep and eat.
I think Do You Carrot All For Me should win because it uses clever word play like Lettuce Marry and With your TURNIP nose.
Roger the Dog has more meaning to me because it is a funny poem about a lazy dog, and all the dog wants to do is sleep and eat.
ReplyDeleteI can make a connection with Roger the Dog. My dog will never get up when he is laying somewhere where he is comfterbul.
I choose Roger the Dog because it has more meaning to me.
The first poem I read was "Do You Carrot All for Me". It uses word play and the rhyme scheme is ABCDA.
ReplyDeleteThe second poem I read was "Rodger the Dog". It is about a lazy dog who doesn't really do anything. It uses AABBCCDD rhyme schemes.
I think the winner should be Rodger the dog because I like the rhymes and my dog is the same way. My dog is the same way like Rodger. I think that the word play was fabulous.
Roger The Dog is about a dog who is super lazy, except for when he sees food.
ReplyDeleteDo You Carrot All For Me is about someone asking someone if they care for them in a different way.
I think that Do You Carrot All For Me should win, because I like the wordplay.
Do You Carrot All For Me uses lots of wordplay.
ReplyDeleteRodger The Dog is a poem about a lazy dog. Its rhyme scheme is, AABBCCDD.
I think the winner is Rodger The Dog because it has more meaning to me.
I think that Do you Carrot all for Me has a deeper meaning. I think this because it reminds me of my rabbit.
ReplyDeleteI made a connection with Roger the Dog. The connection I made was that my dog is lazy and LOVES food.
I think that Do you Carrot all for me should win.
Sorry I forgot to add this... I love how Do you Carrot all for me uses word play.
ReplyDeleteI think that Do You Carrot All For Me is deeper in thought and meaning. It has great writers craft and rhyme scheme.
ReplyDeleteConnection with Roger the dog. My connection is text to self. My cat is lazy and adores food
Do You Carrot For Me's meaning is about love and vegetables. My connection is that I like vegetables too, but sometimes I do use wordplays with vegetables. My favorite part about it was the word choice.
ReplyDeleteThe poem that has more meaning to me is Do You Carrot All For Me? Because even though it is in silly form a person is still asking another person if she cares at all for him.
ReplyDeleteThe poem I can make a connection with is Roger The Dog. Because my aunt and uncles dog Piper is kind of like Roger.
The poem I choose is Do You Carrot All For Me? Because it is a funny poem. Some things I noticed are that it doesn't rhyme and has word play.
For the winner, I chose Do You Carrot At All For Me, because it has clever wordplay. I also chose this poem because it is just entertaining! If you made a math problem out of words, it would be,:
ReplyDeleteVegetables + Love = Do You Carrot At All For Me?
The poem that means more to me is Roger The Dog because I have a dog.
ReplyDeleteI made a Text-Self connection with Roger The dog. I have a dog that is lazy.
I think that Do you carrot all for me should win. I like it's word play.
Do you carrot at all foe me? Is a poem about a man asking a woman if she cares at all for him but using vegetables and fruits instead of real words.
ReplyDeleteRoger the Dog is a poem about a boy describing his dog. His dog uses all his strength to eat and then all he dose is sleep.
I choose Do you carrot at all for me to win because I really like it's word play for example: If we can cantaloupe. I really think this poem should win because it's got great word play.
The first poem I read was "Roger The Dog". It was about a dog that only eats and sleeps and does nothing else. The second poem I read was "do you carrot all for me?" and it was about a man telling a woman that he loves her and wants to marry her, but he uses fruit names instead of real words. The poem I want to win is "Roger the dog" because it was funnier and I had a connection with my dog.
ReplyDeleteroger the dogs rime scheme is aabbccdd i like that it has ryme. do you carrot all for me is about a girl who is saying do you carrot all for me.
ReplyDeleteRoger the Dog has more meaning to me because I love dogs and because one of my best friends has a lazy dog just like Roger.
ReplyDeleteI made a connection with ,Do You Carrot At All For Me, because I have a dog that is like the person in the story always needing to know if he is loved.
I choose ,Roger The Dog, has the winner. I liked the poem and I thought it had good writers craft.